UHRC Chairperson Faces Scrutiny Over Case Management Practices

Mariam Wangadya, the Chairperson of the Uganda Human Rights Commission (UHRC), faced sharp questioning from legislators on the Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Committee. The committee members scrutinized the commission’s handling of public complaints concerning human rights violations. Specifically, accusations were leveled against Wangadya for allegedly making decisions on cases without consulting other commissioners.

Appearing before the committee, Wangadya defended her actions, stating that many cases dismissed prematurely involved individuals she characterized as “hardcore criminals.” She cited an instance of a man convicted of defiling his niece who then filed a complaint against the police for prolonged detention. Wangadya argued that entertaining such cases would send a negative message to crime victims and could undermine justice.

She further explained that some cases were closed without full hearings to prevent criminals from using the commission to evade culpability. Wangadya expressed concerns about forged medical reports accompanying torture cases, which she said could lead to institutional bias against the state if accepted.

However, lawmakers like Hon. George Musisi and Hon. Richard Senteza challenged her stance. Musisi asserted that the law does not permit torture or rights violations, regardless of an individual’s criminal status. Senteza questioned the procedural documentation for case dismissals, citing reports from other commissioners about “unceremonious” file closures.

Hon. Anna Adeke highlighted cases closed by the UHRC that allegedly did not meet hearing standards, suggesting unilateral decision-making and raising public concerns about impartiality. Wangadya clarified that the complainants she referred to as “hardcore criminals” were individuals already serving prison sentences, many for offenses like child defilement.

The committee also delved into Wangadya’s reported intention to resign, which she explained was a confidential letter to the President that was leaked. She referred the committee to the Attorney General’s guidance, affirming her position as substantive chairperson.

The Committee Chairperson, Hon. John Teira, directed Wangadya to provide written responses to all concerns raised by the MPs on a future date.

Source: Parliament of Uganda