DNA Tests Don't Break Families, Deception Does

The recent DNA test results for the late Kadongo Kamu singer Prince Job Paul Kafeero’s children, which confirmed only four out of 25 claimants as his biological offspring, have reopened a sensitive societal debate. This situation brings to mind Archbishop Kaziimba Mugalu’s past sermon discouraging DNA tests, suggesting a Joseph-like acceptance of children regardless of biological certainty. While the Archbishop’s intent may have been pastoral, aiming to maintain family unity, his stance overlooks the fundamental issue of deception.

Family and succession disputes are frequent in Uganda, often leading to prolonged conflict. The Kafeero family saga, for instance, has spanned nearly two decades. DNA testing, however, offers a scientifically reliable method to ascertain biological paternity, a crucial step in resolving such disputes. More importantly, every child possesses an inherent right to know their true parentage. Withholding this truth constitutes a profound injustice.

Historically, law relied on the presumption of legitimacy for children born within marriage. However, with the advent of highly accurate DNA testing, such legal presumptions are becoming archaic. The English Court of Appeal has affirmed that in paternity disputes, the interests of justice are best served by establishing the truth using the most advanced scientific evidence, rather than convenient fictions.

Concealing paternity, however painful the truth might be, ultimately harms the child. Children deserve clarity about their biological identity, not the burden of unresolved doubts and lifelong deception. As the Bible states, “You shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free” (John 8:32). Parents have a moral responsibility to be honest, particularly with their children, who are innocent beings.

The Kafeero case, where 21 children were not biologically related to the singer, exemplifies the devastating impact of deferred truth. The betrayal felt in such situations often stems not from the biological reality itself, but from the years of dishonesty. Ultimately, uncovering the truth, though emotionally challenging, is kinder than perpetuating a falsehood that burdens the child.

https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/oped/commentary/dna-doesn-t-break-families-deception-does-5512364